sdllibs meta pkg fails to install due to missing speex

[Disreali]

Occurs on hrev43809-4h nightly.

'installoptionalpackage -a sdllibs' fails because the speex-1.2-git-r1a3-x86-gcc4-2011-05-26.zip file does not exist at ​http://haiku-files.org/files/optional-packages/lib/

[Disreali]

All that this needs is a gcc4 optional pkg of speex built and placed in ​http://haiku-files.org/files/optional-packages/lib/.

[kallisti5]

korli, you may have plans here (hrev43846) and I don't want to touch it.

SDL relied on speex-1.2-git-r1a3-x86-gcc4-2011-05-26.zip... there is a newer package at ​http://haiku-files.org/files/optional-packages/lib/speex-1.2rc1-x86-gcc4-2012-03-12.zip but it was never pointed to in OptionalPackages.

Thoughts?

[kallisti5]

Went ahead and linked newer speex package in hrev43890

See if it works... if not we should rebuild sdl and friends.

[Disreali]

Actually, it is Xiphlibs and its dependencies that should be rebuilt.

It is Xiphlibs, one of 'SDLlibs' dependencies, that is the issue. It is the 'Xiphlibs' metapkg that includes speex. Now that speex is already included in the build as a requirement of ffmpeg, I expect that we should not be re-installing it and others as part of the 'Xiphlibs' pkg.

As it is now, If someone installs the xiphlibs pkg they will be overwriting libogg, libthoera, libvorbis, and speex with older versions.

According to the /boot/common/data/optional-packages/OptionalBuildFeatures ffmpeg installs the following:

# FFmpeg
local ffmpegBaseURL = http://haiku-files.org/files/optional-packages/lib ;
if $(TARGET_ARCH) = x86 {
	if $(HAIKU_GCC_VERSION[1]) >= 4 {
		HAIKU_FFMPEG_FILE = ffmpeg-0.10-x86-gcc4-2012-03-19.zip ;
		HAIKU_SPEEX_FILE = speex-1.2rc1-x86-gcc4-2012-03-12.zip ;
		HAIKU_LIBTHEORA_FILE = libtheora-1.1.1-x86-gcc4-2012-03-12.zip ;
		HAIKU_LIBVORBIS_FILE = libvorbis-1.3.2-x86-gcc4-2012-03-12.zip ;
		HAIKU_LIBOGG_FILE = libogg-1.3.0-x86-gcc4-2012-03-12.zip ;
		HAIKU_LIBVPX_FILE = libvpx-1.0.0-x86-gcc4-2012-03-14.zip ;
	} else {
		HAIKU_FFMPEG_FILE = ffmpeg-0.10-x86-gcc2-2012-03-19.zip ;
		HAIKU_SPEEX_FILE = speex-1.2rc1-x86-gcc2-2012-03-11.zip ;
		HAIKU_LIBTHEORA_FILE = libtheora-1.1.1-x86-gcc2-2012-03-11.zip ;
		HAIKU_LIBVORBIS_FILE = libvorbis-1.3.2-x86-gcc2-2012-03-11.zip ;
		HAIKU_LIBOGG_FILE = libogg-1.3.0-x86-gcc2-2012-03-11.zip ;
		HAIKU_LIBVPX_FILE = libvpx-1.0.0-x86-gcc2-2012-03-14.zip ;

/boot/common/data/optional-packages/OptionalPackageDependencies states:

OptionalPackageDependencies SDLLibs : XiphLibs libmad libmikmod Libmng libmodplug physfs

And Xiphlib installs:

# XiphLibs
if [ IsOptionalHaikuImagePackageAdded XiphLibs ] {
	if $(TARGET_ARCH) != x86 {
		Echo "No optional package XiphLibs available for $(TARGET_ARCH)" ;
	} else if $(HAIKU_GCC_VERSION[1]) >= 4 {
		InstallOptionalHaikuImagePackage
			flac-1.2.1-r1a3-x86-gcc4-2011-05-26.zip
			: $(baseURL)/lib/flac-1.2.1-r1a3-x86-gcc4-2011-05-26.zip ;
		InstallOptionalHaikuImagePackage
			libao-1.0.0-r1a3-x86-gcc4-2011-05-26.zip
			: $(baseURL)/lib/libao-1.0.0-r1a3-x86-gcc4-2011-05-26.zip ;
		InstallOptionalHaikuImagePackage
			libogg-1.2.2-r1a3-x86-gcc4-2011-05-26.zip
			: $(baseURL)/lib/libogg-1.2.2-r1a3-x86-gcc4-2011-05-26.zip ;
		InstallOptionalHaikuImagePackage
			libtheora-1.1.1-r1a3-x86-gcc4-2011-05-26.zip
			: $(baseURL)/lib/libtheora-1.1.1-r1a3-x86-gcc4-2011-05-26.zip ;
		InstallOptionalHaikuImagePackage
			libvorbis-1.3.2-r1a3-x86-gcc4-2011-05-26.zip
			: $(baseURL)/lib/libvorbis-1.3.2-r1a3-x86-gcc4-2011-05-26.zip ;
		InstallOptionalHaikuImagePackage
			speex-1.2-git-r1a3-x86-gcc4-2011-05-26.zip
			: $(baseURL)/lib/speex-1.2-git-r1a3-x86-gcc4-2011-05-26.zip ;
		InstallOptionalHaikuImagePackage
			vorbis-tools-1.4.0-r1a3-x86-gcc4-2011-05-26.zip
			: $(baseURL)/lib/vorbis-tools-1.4.0-r1a3-x86-gcc4-2011-05-26.zip ;
	} else {
		InstallOptionalHaikuImagePackage
			flac-1.2.1-r1a3-x86-gcc2-2011-05-19.zip
			: $(baseURL)/lib/flac-1.2.1-r1a3-x86-gcc2-2011-05-19.zip ;
		InstallOptionalHaikuImagePackage
			libao-1.0.0-r1a3-x86-gcc2-2011-05-19.zip
			: $(baseURL)/lib/libao-1.0.0-r1a3-x86-gcc2-2011-05-19.zip ;
		InstallOptionalHaikuImagePackage
			libogg-1.2.2-r1a3-x86-gcc2-2011-05-19.zip
			: $(baseURL)/lib/libogg-1.2.2-r1a3-x86-gcc2-2011-05-19.zip ;
		InstallOptionalHaikuImagePackage
			libtheora-1.1.1-r1a3-x86-gcc2-2011-05-19.zip
			: $(baseURL)/lib/libtheora-1.1.1-r1a3-x86-gcc2-2011-05-19.zip ;
		InstallOptionalHaikuImagePackage
			libvorbis-1.3.2-r1a3-x86-gcc2-2011-05-19.zip
			: $(baseURL)/lib/libvorbis-1.3.2-r1a3-x86-gcc2-2011-05-19.zip ;
		InstallOptionalHaikuImagePackage
			speex-1.2-git-r1a3-x86-gcc2-2011-05-26.zip
			: $(baseURL)/lib/speex-1.2-git-r1a3-x86-gcc2-2011-05-26.zip ;
		InstallOptionalHaikuImagePackage
			vorbis-tools-1.4.0-r1a3-x86-gcc2-2011-05-19.zip
			: $(baseURL)/lib/vorbis-tools-1.4.0-r1a3-x86-gcc2-2011-05-19.zip ;

[kallisti5]

eeeeeeh.

I thought that as well originally... however what it is doing is providing a binary speex (and vorbis, etc) binary package to ffmpeg so it can link it into ffmpeg... however if you check the libraries on a recent Haiku system, the speex library isn't anywhere to be found (libspeex.a or something it was called)

unless I missed something.

But yeah, either way a Xiphlibs meta package would be good. Not sure of the space requirements however of having it installed by default. :\

[diver]

OptionalBuildFeatures is different from OptionalPackages and doesn't install its' deps.

[scottmc]

Most of the SDLLibs have seen new releases this year, so they should all be rebuilt. I plan to do this soon... I'll probably rebuild most everything that's in HaikuPorts libpak.

[Disreali]

Is this still a valid issue? I've not been able to run Haiku for quite some time, so I can not test.

[korli]

Closing as rebuilds were done as part of release A4