MediaPlayer does not hold settings

[vidrep]

hrev55046 x86_64

MediaPlayer -> settings -> resume

When set to "ask every time", it will fall back to "always" when resuming playback of a media file.

[vidrep]

The commit that I suspect broke MediaPlayer settings: ​https://git.haiku-os.org/haiku/commit/?id=6375ef053d7770a8af1389fda494fac25c131360

[vidrep]

The commit that I suspect broke MediaPlayer settings: ​https://git.haiku-os.org/haiku/commit/?id=6375ef053d7770a8af1389fda494fac25c131360

[shaka]

This can be fixed by removing the settings file /boot/home/config/settings/MediaPlayer and relaunching.

[mmu_man]

That's because the sign of the fields have been changed, so the code does find a "resume" field in the message but with the wrong type, and it can't replace it.

Maybe we should add code to convert the old settings.

[modeenf]

But how can this commit brake that? it's the same code(more or less) ​https://git.haiku-os.org/haiku/commit/?id=6375ef053d7770a8af1389fda494fac25c131360

To make a converter we need to know what type it was before. But if we don't do a converter we need to have this workaround in Known fixes in the Release documentation for Beta3

The only thing I can think of can brake this are that now handle uint32 "correct".

Before

uint32
SettingsMessage::GetValue(const char* name, uint32 defaultValue) const
{
	int32 value;
	if (FindInt32(name, &value) != B_OK)
		return defaultValue;
	return (uint32)value;
}

now

uint32
SettingsMessage::GetValue(const char* name, uint32 defaultValue) const
{
	uint32 value;
	if (FindUInt32(name, &value) != B_OK)
		return defaultValue;
	return value;
}

[mmu_man]

That's the thing: it was stored as an int32, and so the new code doesn't find it.

[modeenf]

as we have this for int32 I would say this are bug fixed. So now's the question. Do we make a workaround when we a bug are solved?

I wouldn't, but mention this in the release notes?

[axeld]

What's the big problem in staying compatible? Just also search for int32 after uint32 failed.

[pulkomandy]

Fixed in hrev55056.

[mmu_man]

Except now it does load the value from the settings but is not able to change it.

[mmu_man]

Ok, really fixed in hrev55062, works for me™.