Problems booting Haiku on Gigabyte N3150N-D3V

[danboid]

I have successfully installed Haiku on my Gigabyte N3150N-D3V w/ 8 GB RAM and a SATA 3 SSD. This should make for a nice Haiku machine because its fanless and it seems all the hardware is support except for the iGPU and DVI output, its VGA only it seems.

The problem is that Haiku doesn't boot successfully every time. I'd say it successfully boots to a working desktop once in every 3 or 4 boot attempts.

It always gets past all the of boot icons to where the blue background colour appears but then boot usually stops at that point before the deskbar is shown. Sometimes I'm able to move the cursor whilst other times the cursor doesn't move.

I've found that disabling ACPI in the boot menu increases chances of boot succeeding but it doesn't fix it and boot still frequently fails, just less often. I've also tried experimenting with only using the USB 2 or USB 3 ports and using different keyboards and mice but that hasn't seemed to make any difference.

[diver]

Possibly another variation of launch_daemon race in #17365?

[diver]

Disabling ACPI also disables SMP so it has a slimmer chance to get into this race condition I would guess?

[diver]

Ctrl+Alt+Del and clicking Restart Desktop should work.

[danboid]

I will try doing that next time it fails to boot.

When it boots properly, it takes about 25 seconds to boot from the GRUB menu to the desktop. Is that slower than expected when booting off a SATA 3 SSD? Its slower than I expected because Haiku installs on this same machine in about 40 seconds so I expected booting would be a bit faster.

[danboid]

Haiku crashes if I disable ACPI and choose Restart System from the shutdown menu on this machine.

[diver]

You can enable Enable on screen debug output together with Disable on screen paging (and possibly disabling SMP if you run into KDL) and see where it spends the most time at.

Haiku crashes if I disable ACPI and choose Restart System from the shutdown menu on this machine.

How does it crash?

[tojoko]

@danboid Have you tried hitting super-key + alt + 't' in such a case?

[danboid]

I have attached a screenshot of the KDL error when I reboot with ACPI disabled.

[danboid]

I have enabled the onscreen debug output but I don't see any errors and nor does it seem to pause for a long time on anything.

Using the same SSD it takes 28 seconds to boot into Ubuntu MATE 21.10 so Haiku boots slightly faster but I expected it would've had more of an advantage in boot time than that.

[danboid]

I've managed to successfully boot Haiku 10 times in a row with SMP disabled so I think we can safely say its SMP thats causing my boot probs.

[diver]

PANIC: common_snooze_etc(): called with interrupts disabled, timeout 500000

​https://git.haiku-os.org/haiku/tree/src/system/kernel/thread.cpp?id=5fcc7f71b5c07839ca115a008462ee54f94f29a8#n1380

Does it KDL immediately after pressing Ctrl+Alt+Del?

[danboid]

When I boot with ACPI disabled it KDLs immediately after I click on Restart system in the Shutdown menu.

[danboid]

Yes, I can get the desktop to load by hitting CTRL+ALT+DELETE and restarting the desktop when I can move the cursor. If the cursor isn't moveable, pushing CTRL+ALT+DELETE doesn't do anything.