Opened 7 years ago
Last modified 7 years ago
#13666 new bug
Issues with SMART attributes of SSD
Reported by: | Giova84 | Owned by: | nobody |
---|---|---|---|
Priority: | normal | Milestone: | Unscheduled |
Component: | Drivers/Disk/ATA | Version: | R1/Development |
Keywords: | Cc: | ||
Blocked By: | Blocking: | ||
Platform: | x86 |
Description
Haiku hrev51346 gcc2h
Five days ago I installed an SSD on my computer: a Samsung 850 EVO - 250 GB. I made two 125 GB partitions (well, since the disk shows 232 GB, these partition have a size of 116 GB): on the first one there is Windows 7 on NTFS, and on the second partition there is Haiku on BeFS (filesystem blocks of this partition are set to 4096 bytes).
On Windows 7 I also installed "Samsung Magician" utility and also CrystalDiskInfo, to check the S.M.A.R.T status of the drive. I discovered these issues when I reboot (in particular cases) or I shutdown Haiku: there are two bad SMART attributes which increase.
These SMART attributes are the following [1]:
ID # 235 - Power Recovery Count (EB - POR Recovery Count): A count of the number of sudden power off cases. If there is a sudden power off, the firmware must recover all of the mapping and user data during the next power on. This is a count of the number of times this has happened.
This one increase every time that I shutdown Haiku. I can say it for sure, since after that I shutdown Windows 7, it doesn't increase.
The second SMART attribute is
ID # 199 - C7 - CRC Error Count: The number of Cycle Redundancy Check (CRC) errors. If there is a problem between the host and the DRAM or NAND flash, the CRC engine will tally the error and store it in this attribute.
This one increase when I do a forced reboot from Haiku, eg after that I trigger a KDL from which I cannot exit cleanly (eg with the es
command). Also here, I can say it for sure, since when I reboot Windows 7, this value doesn't increase.
After some researching on Google, I also read that this SMART status, sometimes, could be caused by a faulty SATA cable: I have also changed the SATA cable, and however I verirified that occurs only in the described case.
I have to say that when I cleanly reboot Haiku, these SMART attributes doesn't increase: they occurs only on shutdown and on forced reboot due to some KDLs (a KDL which often occurs, eg, when I run the fstrim
command from Terminal). The SSD is new and so the Haiku partition, so I see no way of an Hardware cause. From Windows 7 is always fine: it doesn't increase these values.
If a run checkfs
, however, no errors are reported.
I had similar issues in past, on my old computer with a mechanical hard disk, cfr ticket:6847 but on an SSD, obviously, I can't hear any hard disk's heads noise :-)
Change History (2)
comment:1 by , 7 years ago
comment:2 by , 7 years ago
Yes, sound similar. However, differently from ticket:6847#comment:11 where I said:
if I shutdown Haiku from the default shutdown command present in the Deskbar menu, at the next boot i lose some files (also corrupted), instead all is fine if I shutdown Haiku using "shutdown -q"
Now, on another new computer with my newly fresh SSD, I never get filesystem corruptions and I don't lose files after shutdown (regular or quick).
It does indeed sound like the same issue as #6847.