Broadcom 440x Ethernet Disconnects While Browsing

[I_Am_Kor]

hrev52091

I have a Broadcom 440x ethernet port. It works fine if I use Vision, or HaikuDepot but once I try to browser the web (with any browser) it looses connection then connects, then repeats the same message over and over again every few seconds. Even if I close the browser, it still does it.

I have attached a picture of my pci id, a syslog and a listdev.

[waddlesplash]

Please retest after hrev52114.

[waddlesplash]

No reply in 5 months.

[nielx]

Remove milestone for tickets with status = closed and resolution != fixed

[diver]

According to this ​https://discuss.haiku-os.org/t/broadcom-440x/7200/5 it is still the case.

rudolfc, could you please attach your working driver in case somebody wants to test it?

[rudolfc]

correctly working driver

[rudolfc]

So, the above driver works correctly on my Dell inspiron 8600 laptop with Pentium-M 1.5Ghz with Intel Centrino technology inside on current nightlies. Even the oldest current online nightlies do not work with their respective driver (constantly disconnect if I generate ethernet traffic).

Additions to that:

• the working driver works OK if I start the laptop with mains power. It will run at 1.5Ghz.
• When I start the laptop on its (full) battery it will run at 600Mhz and even this driver version will constantly disconnect during traffic then.
• removing mains when already running apparantly keeps it running at 1.5Ghz (zo the 'about' Haiku box tells me at least: is that live updated with the speed thing??). Looks like also the ethernet keeps working OK then (Quick test).
• When started on battery, and later plugging in mains keeps the laptop running at 600Mhz (so 'about' tells me)
• When running on 600Mhz the system time runs much faster than realtime. 1.6/0.6 times as fast?
• the quick system time on 600Mhz has been there as long as I can remember (on Haiku).

[bruno]

Is there some testing needed? Because I still have this laptop but it is not used now!

[rudolfc]

Hi Bruno, Don't really know.

• Maybe you could determine the current version of the driver (nightlies) do not work without constantly disconnecting, while with the one I uploaded installed, this problem occurs much less often. That would then be a confirmation of my findings. I did have a session that went well @600Mhz in the meantime though.
• if your computer supports 64bit (CPU) you might try what happens with nightlies: is 64bit OK or not? I cannot test that because my laptop is a 32bit CPU. (panic when booting 64bit image ;-)

Looks like the driver variants 'touch' a problem, but the source might lie (partly) outside of that driver.. Vague still.

[rudolfc]

I've got an update on this problem. So all in all also the 'stable' version of the driver from an older nightly is not stable. Disconnects, though a bit less, or it starts a bit later after boot. Also, beta 3 has this.

More observations I've done:

• disconnects initially do not happen after a fresh boot
• if, after boot, I want to do networking, I need to start asap (within approx 1 min I'd say). If I delay starting network traffic, disconnects happen directly.
• cycle trough power-off, power-on has no influence, a direct reboot does the same.
• even when having succesfull comms directly after boot for a long time (approx 10 mins), then at some point the disconnects start to happen.
• Yesterday I connected a USB type ethernet adapter and used that for a while: no disconnects whatsoever. This adapter uses another ethernet driver.

Bruno, maybe you can check to see if what I found is the same for you..?

[waddlesplash]

Recent changes to powerstate management in the freebsd compat layer may affect this, see if things are any different with a recent nightly.

[bruno]

I have no problems with Network connection now... Haiku hrev 56184 32bit works ok here..