[usb_disk] transfer error on slot 1 endpoint 3: Stall

[ilfelice]

Howdy,

Trying to boot Haiku from USB on a hp Pavilion Aero 13-be laptop without success.

All boot icons light up, but then the boot process stops.

When I press Alt+Ctrl-Del, a kernel panic occurs (photo attached).

I am also attaching a backtrace, in case it is useful to debug.

Here are the HW specs to the extent that I know:

CPU: AMD K19 (16 cores, AMD Ryzen 7 5800U with Radeon Graphics)
RAM: 16GB
Graphics: 512MB ATI AMD Radeon Graphics (device ID: 1002-1638)
Wifi: Realtek RTL8852AE WiFi 6 802.11ax PCIe Adapter

Let me know if I can provide any further info to help debug.

[ilfelice]

Boot screen + kernel panic

[ilfelice]

Backtrace

[diver]

Does disabling add-ons/kernel/power/cpuidle/intel_cstates in the boot loader change anything? Additionally, you can try to disable SMP.

[ilfelice]

Hi diver.

With the boot options you suggested, the boot stops at the third icon instead.

[diver]

Does it just freeze or panics? If it's the former you can try to enable on screen debug output out together with disabling on-screen paging.

[diver]

Actually, scratch that. I didn't notice that you have all icons light up. In this case try to blacklist radeon_hd driver or just enable fail save graphics driver.

[ilfelice]

Does it just freeze or panics?

It freezes. If then I press the Alt-Ctl-Del keys, it panics.

...try to blacklist radeon_hd driver or just enable fail save graphics driver.

I tried both, with the same result.

[diver]

Then you can also try my suggestion from comment:3.

[ilfelice]

Hi Diver,

Per your suggestions on comment:3, I enabled debug on screen. Screenshot attached (this is where it seems to stop).

[ilfelice]

On screen debug

[ilfelice]

I tried with a different USB drive, and now Haiku boots as long as I enable the fail safe graphics driver option.

The keyboard and trackpad do not work, though. Should I file a separate bug report for this?

[diver]

These issues could be related. Please attach your /var/log/syslog.

[ilfelice]

Syslog on first boot after installation

[ilfelice]

Diver,

I want to mention that the leyboard does work (not the mousepad). and that USB wifi also worked out of tbe box.

[diver]

Could you connect the first USB drive (while being booted in Haiku) and see if you get any xhci errors in your syslog. tail -F /var/log/syslog

[ilfelice]

syslog with original (bad) USB stick

[waddlesplash]

I don't think this is a problem in XHCI but instead is a problem with the usb_disk driver: it does not recover correctly from stalls. It's not especially difficult to induce stalls even in QEMU with the driver, it just doesn't know how to recover from them.

[ilfelice]

Hi waddlesplash,

As it turns out, the problem I reported here only happens with a specific (and quite old) USB stick.

I tried with a couple of different (and newer) memory sticks, and Haiku boots fine (as previously mentioned, with fail-safe graphics).

So, feel free to close this ticket if you see fit.

[ilfelice]

FWIW, I recently installed Beta 4 on the same HW, and cannot reproduce this problem anymore. I suppose it is OK to close this ticket.

[waddlesplash]

Thanks for testing!