Haiku (r26165) does not detect SATA DVD/CDROM drive.

[Bouncer]

Ever since I installed it (several months ago) - Haiku has not been able to recognize my SATA DVD drive.

I am currently testing with Haiku hrev26265.

Previously _{Haiku had no problems with a PATA DVD drive from the same manufacturer.}

I am testing on real hardware. Intel Quad Core CPU. The DVD unit in question is a LITEON Model LH-20A1S12C.

Linux has no problems recognizing (or even installing from) from this SATA DVD. So I know it is in good working order.

Haiku simply cannot see this drive. It does not show up in the mount list. It does not appear on the list if I cycle a CD a few times. Other SATA Hard Drives do register properly.

I will attempt to include my syslog

[anevilyak]

I might be wrong but I thought the SATA driver is currently missing ATAPI support, meaning this won't work yet no matter what you do. Switching to correct component in any case.

[marcusoverhagen]

The AHCI sata driver already supports ATAPI. (works for me :-)

On this machine, the drive is detected, but some ATAPI command seems to fail.

ata command 0xa0 is the PACKET command, more debug output needs to be added to see which ATAPI command is beeing executed.

3386	KERN: [34mahci:[0m AHCIPort::PostReset port 3
3387	KERN: [34mahci:[0m device signature 0xeb140101 (ATAPI)
3388	KERN: [34mahci:[0m AHCIPort::ScsiInquiry port 3
3389	KERN: [34mahci:[0m model number:  LITE-ON DVDRW LH-20A1S                 
3390	KERN: [34mahci:[0m serial number:                     
3391	KERN: [34mahci:[0m firmware rev.: 9L08   
3392	KERN: [34mahci:[0m sg_memcpy phyAddr 0x0325b388, addr 0x83a5b388, size 96
3393	KERN: [34mahci:[0m ahci_get_restrictions, cookie 0x90bc5480
3394	KERN: [34mahci:[0m AHCIPort::ScsiGetRestrictions port 3: isATAPI 1, noAutoSense 1, maxBlocks 256
3395	KERN: publish device: node 0x90c1fc60, path disk/scsi/0/3/0/raw, module generic/block_io/device_v1

3656	KERN: [34mahci:[0m AHCIPort::InterruptErrorHandler port 3, fCommandsActive 0x00000001, is 0x40000001, ci 0x00000001
3657	KERN: [34mahci:[0m ssts 0x00000113
3658	KERN: [34mahci:[0m sctl 0x00000300
3659	KERN: [34mahci:[0m serr 0x00000000
3660	KERN: [34mahci:[0m sact 0x00000000
3661	KERN: [34mahci:[0m Task File Error
3662	KERN: ahci: sata_request::finish ATA_ERR set for command 0xa0
3663	KERN: ahci: sata_request::finish status 0x51, error 0x20

[marcusoverhagen]

Please create a new syslog with hrev26205 or newer. I added error output for ATAPI commands.

[Bouncer]

OK - Here is the latest syslog, for hrev26212

[marcusoverhagen]

Are you sure that a CD is inserted? Can you please insert / cycle a CD and try again?

[Bouncer]

OK.

1) First - I boot a fresh Haiku installation (hrev26212) with an Audio CD

in the DVD drive.

2) Since it does not see the disk - I cycle disk out and back in to the drive.

Again - it does not see it.

3) I remove the Audio CD and load a data CD (an anonymous MS driver install disk).

It does not auto-mount. But I do see an entry in the Mount list and I am able to mount it.

4) Next - I unmount and remove the data CD and re-insert the Audio CD.

Again - it is not recognized.

Have I been mistaken? Does Haiku not support regular audio CD's ?

[axeld]

Definitely works over here with a SATA DVD ROM drive. What audio CD is it? Have you tried different ones?

[marcusoverhagen]

The only failing commands are: "ATAPI packet 00", Test unit ready, fails when no CD is inserted. "ATAPI packet 28", Read, might fail for non-data CDs.

Auto-mounting doesn't seem to work for me, too. Execept during boot.

I don't know why audio CDs don't work. Perhaps B_SCSI_READ_CD uses the wrong command for this CD-ROM.

[marcusoverhagen]

different CD-ROM

[marcusoverhagen]

reproducible here, audio CDs can't be read with CDDA

[marcusoverhagen]

Should be fixed in hrev26332, please test.

[Bouncer]

I am pleased to report that audio CD's in my SATA DVD ROM are now being detected. I was able to mount and unmount the CD's without any incidents. All Files are viewable.

I think this ticket can be closed now.

[axeld]

I just checked on another system of mine, and there the SATA DVD-ROM doesn't seem to work. I'll investigate this before reopening the ticket, though.