Opened 9 years ago

Closed 9 years ago

#6541 closed enhancement (fixed)

ActivityMonitor only using 4 colors on 8 CPUs.

Reported by: jstressman Owned by: phoudoin
Priority: normal Milestone: R1
Component: Applications/ActivityMonitor Version: R1/Development
Keywords: activitymonitor colors Cc: jstressman@…
Blocked By: Blocking:
Has a Patch: no Platform: All


I noticed this on a fresh install of hrev38478 but confirmed that it's been happening for many months (by looking at an old screenshot from 3/19/2010 and confirming it in that as well).

We discussed this on IRC a bit and the discussion seems to hold some other possibly interesting information as well from people much more knowledgeable than I.

(I've tried to trim out the extraneous chatter)

(11:08:03 AM) phoudoin: the fix will be in src/apps/activitymonitor/DataSource.cpp, line 878
(11:08:12 AM) phoudoin: only 4 colors are defined.
(11:09:49 AM) largo: phoudoin: thanks. I'll try some mock-ups. how many colors do you think should be defined?
(11:09:55 AM) largo: just 8 for now until after R1?
(11:10:23 AM) phoudoin: MAX_CPU_COUNT
(11:11:44 AM) phoudoin: B_MAX_CPU_COUNT is set to 8 for R1, yes
(11:11:48 AM) OmniMancer: largo look here on line 880
(11:12:27 AM) OmniMancer: yes otherwise the struct that uses an embedded array of that size is no longer the same size and abi compatability breaks
(11:12:49 AM) phoudoin: OmniMancer: I know that's an ABI issue indeed.
(11:19:25 AM) idefix_xifedi: largo: it is strange that your screenshot shows the middle window with 4 cpu's, two of them having the same colour
(11:19:39 AM) idefix_xifedi: they all should have gotten a different colour...
(11:20:17 AM) OmniMancer: it probably begind picking colours for each column of labels
(11:22:36 AM) idefix_xifedi: but if I understand the code in DataSource.cpp correctly, the colour is directly related to the CPU number (variable 'cpu')
(11:23:49 AM) OmniMancer: oh yes that could still do it
(11:24:08 AM) OmniMancer: it doesn't necessarily have cpu's from 0..number of cores you have
(11:24:54 AM) idefix_xifedi: but then the text should't say CPU 0..number of cores
(11:25:35 AM) idefix_xifedi: as I understand the code, the text "CPU 0" always implies a colour of 200,0,200
(11:26:34 AM) idefix_xifedi: but I have no way to test this, as I only have one signle core CPU in my computer (and a slow one at that)...
(11:34:15 AM) phoudoin: I think that's a bug, idefix_xifedi. A CPUUsageDataSource (implicit CPU #0) is added, but as it report being PerCpu(), other are added by copy from 0 to # CPU. Should have been from 0 to # CPU *except* fro the first data source's CPU.
(11:36:55 AM) phoudoin: which means we've two data source sharing the same data history *and* color.
(11:41:53 AM) idefix_xifedi: not sure if I understood you correctly, but shouldn't the first CPUUsageDataSource not be CPU #0, but the average of all (8) CPU's?
(11:42:40 AM) phoudoin: Not, that's the object of CombinedCPUUsageDataSource...
(11:43:07 AM) idefix_xifedi: yeah sorry, just saw that one in the source code
(11:48:17 AM) phoudoin: Could be related to the previous launch colors stored in settings: maybe "CPU 3 usage color" in 8 CPUs mode was cyan two
(12:12:26 PM) largo: idefix_xifedi: I tested this on the latest nightly build a few hours ago. the problem with the colors is still there.
(12:12:36 PM) largo: I only looked at the old screenshot to confirm whether or not it was a new issue.
(12:13:52 PM) idefix_xifedi: and if you removed the settings file before launching?
(12:18:28 PM) largo: idefix_xifedi: it was on a fresh install on a newly formatted partition.
(12:19:05 PM) idefix_xifedi: then you should open a bug-report about that :)
(12:19:38 PM) largo: will do.

While I had seen in those older shots only 3 colors used for 4 CPUs, I can't seem to replicate that behavior now, so that may very well have been fixed already.

But the 4 colors for 8 CPUs issue is definitely still there. (as only 4 colors are defined, they are reused for any # of CPU over 4)

Attachments (1)

activitymonitor-8cpu.png (33.2 KB) - added by jstressman 9 years ago.
shot of ActivityMonitor showing 4 colors being reused on 8 CPUs

Download all attachments as: .zip

Change History (3)

Changed 9 years ago by jstressman

Attachment: activitymonitor-8cpu.png added

shot of ActivityMonitor showing 4 colors being reused on 8 CPUs

comment:1 Changed 9 years ago by phoudoin

Owner: changed from axeld to phoudoin
Status: newin-progress

comment:2 Changed 9 years ago by phoudoin

Resolution: fixed
Status: in-progressclosed

Fixed in hrev38531.

Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.