Haiku KDLs when plugging in external USB hard drive

[dsuden]

I tried plugging in a small portable Samsung USB hard drive and Haiku immediately went to a KDL screen. I didn't catch the messages on the screen, but will try and do that next time it occurs.

[anevilyak]

Assigning to USB pending further information to correctly classify it. The information on the screen is unfortunately quite critical in terms of determining the culprit. If you can get a photograph of it and attach it, that would be quite helpful. Also, more detailed information about your motherboard chipset and the vendor/product ID of that usb stick would be helpful.

[dsuden]

photo of the KDL info

[dsuden]

Here's a photo. I don't know the chipset data but if I find it out I'll get it posted here.

[anevilyak]

If you have linux on there, the output of lspci and lsusb would suffice (with the stick plugged in).

[korli]

Looking at the usb error, it's not exactly the same "Device not ready" vs "operation timed out".

[mmlr]

Replying to korli:

Looking at the usb error, it's not exactly the same "Device not ready" vs "operation timed out".

And that makes a huge difference, as it points out that the underlying error is a different one.

Can you grab a new photo with the output of the "syslog | tail 50" command in KDL. It should list the SCSI error that lead up to the panic.

[dsuden]

Result of attempt to copy big file to USB stick in 4.1 version

[dsuden]

This is another one that could probably be removed from active at this point. At least in my experience, I don't ever see KDLs when plugging in USB drives anymore.

[vidrep]

I have plugged in a multitude of USB sticks and Seagate GoFlex drives over the past year without a single crash. I agree with Dane, that this ticket is probably safe to close.

[cocobean]

hrev52017 reviewed. Verified external USB sticks formatted in several supported disk formats. All passed.

We can close this ticket. (see #14204)

[vidrep]

I have several SATA HDD with USB adapters that I use for archiving, and have not experienced a KDL with any of them. Probably safe to close this ticket.