Opened 3 years ago

Closed 14 months ago

#17153 closed bug (duplicate)

Crash / Failure to write file on Media Export

Reported by: bronzie94 Owned by: nobody
Priority: normal Milestone: Unscheduled
Component: Kits/Media Kit Version: R1/Development
Keywords: Cc:
Blocked By: #17415 Blocking:
Platform: All

Description

I have been attempting to edit mp3 files in various programs, and export these to various formats. Any app that uses BMediaKit fails, writing a 0 byte file then crashing out (either the whole app, or the export process).

This problem has occurred in the following programs *using the BMediaKit export funtion*

  • BeAE
  • Medo (which works when using ffmpeg and not BMediaKit to export)
  • Clockwerk

It has happened on all Dev/nightly versions of Haiku since the Beta release (had not tried in a long time before). Currently on hrev55274

Attachments (4)

BeAE-995-debug-01-08-2021-14-02-58.report (39.2 KB ) - added by bronzie94 3 years ago.
BeAE crash report on failed export attempt
BeScreenCapture-78368-debug-01-08-2021-23-42-04.report (40.0 KB ) - added by hean8209 3 years ago.
BeScreenCapture report
Clementine_Transcoding_Errors.txt (22.0 KB ) - added by bronzie94 3 years ago.
Transcoding error (BMedia Kit) on R1B3 with native intel HDA - Clementine Transcoder log
MediaConverter-810-debug-29-08-2021-10-56-18.report (30.9 KB ) - added by bronzie94 3 years ago.
Error encountered in MediaConverter copnverting MP3 to OGG

Download all attachments as: .zip

Change History (10)

by bronzie94, 3 years ago

BeAE crash report on failed export attempt

comment:1 by diver, 3 years ago

Can you run it again from Terminal like this: LD_PRELOAD=libroot_debug.so /system/apps/BeAE/BeAE and create a ticket here https://github.com/HaikuArchives/beae/issues

comment:2 by hean8209, 3 years ago

Also affects BeScreenRecorder, cant export any video to disk (AVI/Theora/Matroska export tested)

by hean8209, 3 years ago

BeScreenCapture report

comment:4 by bronzie94, 3 years ago

I have installed R1B3 hrev55181+56 (ie the stable version) fresh on a DIFFERENT Core 2 Duo machine with NATIVE supported HDA audio, and am experiencing the same issues with BeAE (crashing and producing a 0 byte output file).

I also am experiencing 100% failures to transcode .wav files in the audio app Clementine (installed from Haiku Depot). I will attach its error output (it errors out from the operation without crashing or generating any output file at all, except the transcoder log per attached)

by bronzie94, 3 years ago

Transcoding error (BMedia Kit) on R1B3 with native intel HDA - Clementine Transcoder log

comment:5 by bronzie94, 3 years ago

A couple more experiments -

  • Restored my settings on new box back to vanilla - BeAE had same crash/0 byte export file issue
  • Restored by current settings and experimented with "MediaConverter". Attempted to convert an MP3 to otehr audio formats. All failed and wrote 0 byte files, some (like OGG) also caused the app to crash - See attached crash log file.

NB - it seems that maybe the wrong codecs are being paired with containers - they seem off...

by bronzie94, 3 years ago

Error encountered in MediaConverter copnverting MP3 to OGG

comment:6 by pulkomandy, 14 months ago

Blocked By: 17415 added
Resolution: duplicate
Status: newclosed
Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.